BlackChampagne Home

In association with Amazon.comBuy Crap! I get 5%.
Direct donations to cover hosting expenses are also accepted.

Site Information
--What is Black Champagne?
--Cast of Characters & Things
--Your First Time.
--Design Notes
--Quote of the Day Archive
--Phrase of the Moment Archive
--Site Feedback
--Contact/Copyright Info

Blog Archives
--Blogger Archives: June 2005-
--Old Monthly Archives: Jan 2002-May 2005

Reviews Section
Movie Reviews (153)

Ten Most Recent Film Reviews:
--Infernal Affairs -- 5.5
--The Protector/Tom Yum Goong -- 6
--The Limey -- 8
--The Descent -- 6
--Oldboy -- 9.5
--Shaolin Deadly Kicks -- 7
--Mission Impossible III -- 7.5
--V for Vendetta -- 8.5
--Ghost in the Shell 2 -- 8
--Night Watch -- 7.5

Book Reviews (76)
Five Most Recent Book Reviews:
--Cat People -- 4
--Attack Poodles -- 5
--Caught Stealing -- 6
--The Dirt, by Motley Crue -- 7.5
--Harry Potter #6 -- 7

Photos Section
--Flux Photos
--Pet Photos (7 pages)
--Home Decor Photos
--Plant Photos
--Vacation Photos (12 pages)

Articles
See all 234 articles here.

Fiction
Original horror and fantasy short stories.

Mail Bags
Index Page

Features
--Links
--Slang: Internet
--Slang: Dirty
--Slang: Wankisms
--Slang: Sex Acts
--Slang: Fulldeckisms
--Hot or Not?
--Truths in Advertising

Band Name Ratings
(350 Rock Bands Listed)
FAQ -- Feedback
A -- B -- C -- D -- E -- F -- G -- H -- I -- J -- K -- L -- M -- N -- O -- P -- Q -- R -- S -- T -- U -- V -- W -- X -- Y -- Z

Hellgate: London
--The Unofficial HGL Site
--The Hellgate Wiki

Diablo II
--The Unofficial Site
--Flux's Decahedron
--Middle Earth Mod

Locations of visitors to this page

Powered by Blogger.

BlackChampagne -- no longer new; improvement also in question.: Harry Potter Gay Fan Fiction



Wednesday, August 31, 2005  

Harry Potter Gay Fan Fiction


It seems an outrageous title for a post, but since it's exactly what this popular UK Yahoo news article is about, I can hardly be faulted for repeating it. Besides, it's a good read:
As Harry Potter fans speculate what still lies in store for the world's favourite boy wizard, few envisage him leaving Hogwarts and settling into a committed gay relationship with arch foe Draco Malfoy.

But some do.

"Draco's breath is warm against his neck, his body gradually relaxing as Harry holds him, refusing to let go, and Harry discovers this is the most comfortable he's ever been in his entire life."
According to the article, there are numerous fan fiction sites out there, lots of them entirely devoted to stories set in the Harry Potter world. The biggest ones don't allow erotica or porn... but others do:
"I don't feel its my job or anybody else's to say what their kick should be. As long as it's well written, I'll post it," said Vikki Dolenga who set up the adult-themed Potter fanfic site, Restrictedsection.org, in 2002.

Dolenga, 34, a client support specialist for a health care data company in Chicago, insists the stories on her site, which gets close to 200,000 hits a day, are examples of "erotica" rather than pornography. A large number of submissions to the site fall into the category of "slash" fanfic -- so called because it explores homosexual pairings of traditionally straight characters, such as Harry/Draco.

Slash has it origins in fanfics written in the mid-1970s that imagined breathless couplings between Captain Kirk and Mr. Spock from the iconic "Star Trek" series. With content ranging from unfulfilled homoerotic yearnings to the sexually explicit, slash writing is, perhaps surprisingly, dominated by straight women writers.

"I find it extremely liberating," said Lauren, 28, an advertising copywriter in New York. "I'm not sure why I prefer slash to het (heterosexual) ... maybe I just find it easier to write smut from a distance."
There's even a quote from perennially-delusional sourpuss Anne Rice, who, I must admit, was smart enough to pull up stakes and get the hell out of New Orleans several months before it became the southern-most cove in Lake Pontchartrain.
The growing, Internet-generated popularity of fanfic has attracted mixed reactions from the original authors of the works being co-opted.

"I do not allow fan fiction," Vampire Chronicles novelist Anne Rice wrote in a statement on her official website in 2000. "The characters are copyrighted. It upsets me terribly to even think about fan fiction with my characters," Rice said.

Potter creator JK Rowling and her publishers have adopted a more conciliatory approach, objecting only to fanfic that is sexually explicit, violent or profane.

Websites like Restrictdsection.org have received cease-and-desist orders, but can usually remain up and running by simply adding registration and password procedures that deter people under 18 years of age. "It's 2005 and we're still here," Dolenga said. "Though I don't think we'll be winning one of (Rowling's) best website awards."
Like everything else (including hurricane-generated flooding) I'm sure this is all much funnier from a distance, and when it's my story and my characters some hack is throwing into bed together, I'll find it all far less amusing. Feel free to point out what a goddamned hypocrite I am then. Kthx.
Comments:

I did a course on media audiences and a section was on fandom and fanfiction. Most writers of fanfiction enjoy the original setting and characters, but find that they aren't telling the sort of stories that they want to tell, so they go and write them themselves.

I think authors should be honored and proud that people connect with their basic characters in such ways that they would want to write their own stories using those characters.


Interestingly for some fandoms there are large subgroups in the fandom that feel the original creators of the show have lost touch with their characters and are ruining them, in much the same way that Anne Rice things people are ruining her characters. For example there was one person who said she watched a particular episode of Star Trek with all her friends, and immediately after it was over they re-wrote the story amongst themselves to better fit their idea of the characters - what this person should have done or said instead of what they did do - because they felt that the episode was not in line with the rest of the series' portrayal of the characters.


 

I was going to comment about Dojinshi, but forgot in the initial post. I wrote about it 2.5 years ago, and as that post explains, it's basically professionally-produced comic fan fiction in Japan. Something completely alien to the copyright laws and concepts of the US and other Western Nations.

The concept in japan seems to be "why worry about people keeping our characters and worlds popular by doing more work on it for free?" Funny how it gets into a sort of "mine mine mine" pissing contest elsewhere, with Anne Rice and others of her opinion objecting to fans who like her work so much they're willing to spend hours and hours thinking and writing and reading about it on their own. How can that not help her book sales, in terms of keeping existing fans interested and turning new readers onto her stuff? No matter how much people enjoy the fan fic stuff, you know they're going to have to buy any new "canon" material, by the original author.


 

I think the main reason is simply due to the way copyright law is written. If you don't actively try and protect your brand and allow copyright infringement, then it's possible that you'll lose your copyright entirely.

So some people get really really concerned about this, even though I don't think it happens very often, and go nazi on everyone who they see as a threat, whereas other people don't mind as long as there are some general guidelines followed (generally they have to be non-commercial derivations).

This divide is pretty clear in game modding when compared to other forms of media - almost every computer game developer on earth will either support modding or turn a blind eye to it, as long as it's not profitable. However going forward, media creators are becoming less and less concerned with co-operative use of their trademarks etc, simply because thriving fanbases are generally more profitable, and fanfiction and the like is a great way to fuel and keep a fanbase alive.

I sent Isolde an email earlier in the year (seems I've lost it) asking about Blizzard's stance on modding, particularly in light of the whole bnetd thing. He didn't think bnetd was any kind of subtle swipe at modders (who were the main users on the system), mainly because Blizzard seemed to be completely oblivious to the mod-scene that existed. He said that other people at the Blizz N office didn't mind D2 mods, although he didn't think any one there actually played any of them. No one minded that he spent so long on 1.10 either, primarily re-writing a lot of the internal workings for mod-makers use (also to clean up the dogs breakfast of a mess that it was).


 

And just for the record, I haven't read any of this gay harry fanfic, although I think Tom has. He's quite sad in a lot of ways.


 

Post a Comment << Home

Archives

May 2005   June 2005   July 2005   August 2005   September 2005   October 2005   November 2005   December 2005   January 2006   February 2006   March 2006   April 2006   May 2006   June 2006   July 2006   August 2006   September 2006   October 2006   November 2006   December 2006   January 2007   February 2007   March 2007   April 2007   May 2007   June 2007   July 2007   August 2007   September 2007   October 2007   November 2007   December 2007   January 2008   February 2008   March 2008   April 2008   May 2008   June 2008   July 2008   August 2008   September 2008   October 2008   November 2008   December 2008   January 2009   February 2009   March 2009   April 2009   May 2009   June 2009   July 2009   August 2009   September 2009   October 2009   November 2012  

All site content copyright "Flux" (Eric Bruce), 2002-2007.